"Surface Thinking"
by Todd Hayen
"People don’t care because they don’t know. Simple as that. I know I’ve been through this a million times, but I just don’t think I’ve nailed it. Maybe now. It’s nuance, still, but it’s something more than I have written about before.
My stepson got married a few weeks ago, and I officiated the ceremony. Even though I did not know everyone who attended, I had the chance to talk to a lot of people. The wedding, by the way, was beautiful. I’m not really a fan of all the expense and hoopla that goes into these events, but I do believe rituals like weddings are important for keeping the psyche healthy.
Most people these days still adhere to the rituals of dressing up, looking their best, and formalizing the affair as much as they feel comfortable with - “I do” statements, walking down the aisle, the formal declaration of “husband and wife,” even “kissing the bride.” So it was fun and meaningful in that regard.
The thing I found strangely disturbing - and what inspired this article - were the odd conversations I had over the two days we were in attendance. Everyone involved, and most of the guests I am presuming, were liberals. Many, I am sure, would classify as woke, or at least leaning toward the radical left. I had one conversation with a distant family member who will remain unnamed (of course) who proceeded to tell me how Trump was the “most evil man in the world today” and how horrible it was that he was “in charge of the world.”
Well, Trump is certainly an ass, and he very well may be doing some horrible things, but he isn’t, by far, “the most evil man in the world.” And is he “in charge”? Maybe - and this is a stretch - he has power in the US to do his bidding, but he is hardly “in charge of the world.”
I suppose I can see how people see it this way, particularly considering recent events, but there is so much nuance out there regarding what’s going on in the world that we can hardly draw such black-and-white conclusions. I may know 10% of the whole story (that’s stretching it); you may know 20% plus; and I am sure there are people out there who know far more than 50%. But these people I talked to at the wedding (not just the conversation about evil Trump) probably know less than 1%.
Of course, the obvious reason is the source of information these one-percenters use. I doubt a single one of them reads anything but the New York Times, the Washington Post, or listens to NPR or some other tainted news source. Or, of course, they get their social-media news fix from Facebook, Instagram, or X. They join other liberal echo chambers where the aforementioned news sources’ propaganda is chewed up, spit out, and mangled beyond recognition - like a pack of hyenas devouring roadkill.
No wonder. How do I get to 10%? I read any and everything I can get my hands on. Mostly books by contrarian authors such as Orwell, Huxley, Patrick Wood, Desmet, RFK Jr., Malone, Whitney Webb, Michael Nehls, and Iain McGilchrist (among many others). I also read a lot of conventional history and conventional views.
I read Substacks, alternative news articles (OffGuardian, of course), and listen to and watch podcasts - not just the alternative stuff, but also the mainstream crap that is out there (you can’t avoid that nonsense). And after all that, I would hardly call myself “well informed.” But I do know more than the surface stuff. I know enough to know I don’t know enough. They don’t.
And there is good reason they don’t absorb the stuff they just so happen to come across that is different from the usual crap they gnaw on. I have gone over this dozens of times, so you all know it well. It isn’t just that they don’t read, listen to, or look at anything outside the mainstream - if they fall over something by accident, their mental system completely ignores it. We have been trying for years to get this stuff to them, and they are blind to it. But by some miracle, if it were injected into their brains - bypassing their woke filtering system - and if they were not brain-dead, they actually would know something more than the surface gives them.
So, what’s my point? Isn’t this the same thing we have all been griping about since the beginning? Yes and no. I actually thought at one time that “critical thinking” was the primary issue. That even if more detailed information were forced into these resistant brains, they would not be able to decipher it and come up with conclusions similar to ours. Not that they weren’t smart enough (IQ has not diminished substantially enough among the liberal population to make that a plausible explanation). It would just be a matter of a thinking method, and I believed they could not think critically.
Now I am not so sure. Now I wonder whether, if they had the details in their brains, they would be able to piece it all together and make sense of it. Take this whole Carney/Trump thing, for example. This is a clear circus of nonsense. On both sides. If people only listen to Carney complaining about what a bully Trump is, how he “surprised” him with new deal points at the last minute of negotiations, slapping his hand for trading with China, and claiming the French language isn’t good enough to consider - along with listening to Trump calling Carney “governor” and renaming Lake Ontario to Lake America (why not Lake Trump?) - how could anyone even begin to think they are getting any information at all from which to draw an intelligent conclusion?
Read something, sheepsters! Go deeper. What do the actual economic negotiators say? U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer and Canada’s Minister responsible for Canada-U.S. Trade, Dominic LeBlanc (along with Chief Negotiator Janice Charette)? What about the dozens of other highly qualified people working on these trade issues behind the scenes? What are they saying? It is astounding to me that people only listen to these two numb-nuts when it comes to such complicated issues.
Obviously, most people are just too lazy to do more than listen to mainstream media sound bites. It is simply too much work to shove real information into a hardened and swollen brain. Have these people all lost their ability to think critically? Yes. But it doesn’t take a genius to put two and two together. The people I am talking about not only lack critical thinking. They lack the ability to think at all."